Charge: Battery, disorderly conduct, and intimidation
Arrest Date: February 6, 2007
Franchise: Indiana Pacers
Details: Tinsley, along with teammate Marquis Daniels, were arrested following a bar brawl in Indianapolis. Tinsley and Daniels allegedly punched the bar manager repeatedly in the head, causing a laceration to his forehead and a lost tooth. Another Pacer teammate, Keith McLeod, was reportedly involved but did not face charges.